Should You Convert Part of Your IRA to a Roth IRA?
A Roth conversion can be a useful retirement-planning tool, but it generally creates taxable income in the year of conversion. Before moving money, it is important to understand how the conversion may affect your broader retirement income, taxes, Medicare premiums, and long-term goals.
Converting eligible pre-tax IRA or retirement-plan assets to a Roth IRA generally means paying income tax on the converted amount now. In exchange, qualified Roth IRA withdrawals may be tax-free in the future. Whether that tradeoff makes sense depends on your current and expected tax situation, income needs, account balances, and available cash to pay the tax.
Roth conversion planning is about more than this year’s tax bill. It requires looking at how a conversion may affect current and future tax brackets, required minimum distributions, Medicare premiums, Social Security taxation, estate goals, and the amount of cash available to pay the tax. A coordinated plan can help determine whether to convert, how much to convert, and when the timing may be most favorable.
Lower-income years before retirement
A temporary drop in income may create an opportunity to convert part of an account at a lower marginal tax rate than in higher-income years.
Creating tax diversification
Holding a mix of pre-tax, Roth, and taxable accounts may provide more flexibility when deciding where retirement income should come from.
Key Factors in Roth Conversion Planning
In some situations, paying tax on a conversion today may help you manage taxes or flexibility later on. Examples can include:
Years between retirement and RMDs
The period after earned income stops but before required minimum distributions begin may provide a useful planning window for partial conversions.
Leaving assets to heirs
Roth assets may provide tax advantages for certain beneficiaries, but inherited-account rules and the beneficiary’s own tax situation still matter.
Managing future RMDs
Converting some pre-tax assets can reduce future required minimum distributions, although the current tax cost should be weighed carefully.
Using outside cash for tax
Paying conversion taxes from non-retirement funds may allow more of the converted amount to remain invested inside the Roth IRA.
When a Roth Conversion May Not Make Sense
A Roth conversion may be less attractive when the current tax cost outweighs the expected long-term benefit or when it creates other financial complications.
-
The conversion would push part of your income into a substantially higher tax bracket.
-
You would need to use retirement assets to pay the conversion tax.
-
The added income could increase Medicare premiums.
-
You may need the converted funds within a relatively short period.
-
You reasonably expect to be in a lower tax bracket in retirement.
-
State income taxes make the current timing less favorable.
-
The conversion would interfere with cash reserves or other near-term goals.
Key Factors to Review
Before deciding whether a Roth conversion fits your plan, review the tax, income, healthcare, and estate-planning factors that may affect the outcome.
-
Current and expected future tax brackets
-
The amount and timing of each conversion
-
Medicare IRMAA thresholds
-
Social Security taxation
-
Required minimum distributions
-
Available cash to pay conversion taxes
-
Estate and beneficiary goals
-
State income-tax considerations
-
Charitable-giving plans
-
Other deductions, credits, and income expected that year
Partial Conversions Can Provide More Control
A Roth conversion does not have to involve the entire account at once. Converting smaller amounts over multiple years may provide more control over taxable income, tax brackets, Medicare premiums, and cash flow. The appropriate amount can vary from year to year based on income, deductions, market values, and changes in tax law.
Roth Conversion FAQs
Here are a few common questions people ask when they start exploring Roth conversions.
Is a Roth conversion taxable?
Generally, the taxable portion of a traditional IRA or eligible pre-tax retirement account converted to a Roth IRA is included in your taxable income for that year. Any after-tax basis in the account may reduce the taxable amount, so accurate tax records are important.
Can I convert only part of my IRA?
Yes. You can generally convert part of a traditional IRA rather than the entire account. Partial conversions may help manage taxable income and allow the strategy to be spread across multiple years.
Can I undo a Roth conversion?
No. Roth conversions completed after 2017 generally cannot be reversed or recharacterized back to a traditional IRA. That makes it especially important to estimate the tax impact before completing the conversion.
Does a Roth conversion affect Medicare premiums?
It can. A conversion increases modified adjusted gross income and may result in higher Medicare Part B and Part D premiums in a later year. Medicare generally uses income reported on the tax return from two years earlier when determining income-related premium adjustments.
Should I convert before RMDs begin?
The years before required minimum distributions begin may provide a useful planning window, particularly after retirement income declines. However, the appropriate timing depends on tax brackets, Medicare considerations, cash available for taxes, and expected future income. Traditional retirement accounts are generally subject to RMD rules, while Roth IRA owners are not required to take lifetime RMDs.
Evaluate the Tax Impact Before You Convert
A Roth conversion can affect more than your current tax bill. DR Wealth can help you evaluate the timing, conversion amount, retirement-income impact, Medicare considerations, and long-term tradeoffs before you make a decision.
Investment advisory services are offered through Savvy Advisors, Inc., an SEC-registered investment advisor. DR Wealth and Dustin Roberts do not provide tax or legal advice. Roth conversion decisions should be coordinated with a qualified tax professional based on your individual circumstances.
About the Author
Dustin Roberts is the founder of DR Wealth and a wealth advisor with Savvy Advisors. He helps individuals, families, educators, veterans, and business owners coordinate retirement accounts, investments, lending decisions, insurance, and long-term financial planning.
Written by Dustin Roberts
Founder, DR Wealth
Wealth Advisor | Mortgage Loan Originator
NMLS #692288